Auswertung des sppro.de-Contests #14

500 Planeten, 5 Durchgänge pro Planet.
Tabellen sind sortierbar!

Ein paar Worte

Leider gab es diesmal nur 4 Einsendungen (+ meinen eigenen Algorithmus). Wie erwartet war niemand in der Lage einen Algorithmus zu entwickeln, der immer das optimale Ergebnis liefert (dies ist vermutlich in einer Sekunde gar nicht möglich).
Die beiden besten Algorithmen, die von Helmut und mir, sind mit relativ ausführlichen Kommentaren versehen, in denen die Funktionsweise erläutert wird. Die Algorithmen sind sich ähnlich. Je nach Planet ist mal der eine, mal der andere besser, jedoch ist Helmuts Algorithmus insgesamt leicht besser (dafür überwiegt jedoch die Anzahl der Planeten, bei denen mein Algorithmus ein besseres Ergebnis liefert, nur ist die Verbesserung dann eher klein).
Darkrel hat sich an einem genetischen Algorithmus versucht, der mit wenig Code auskommt und nach seiner Aussage innerhalb von nur einer Stunde programmiert wurde. Dafür kann sich das Ergebnis durchaus sehen lassen, wobei noch einige Performance-Verbesserungen möglich gewesen wären.
Die Algorithmen von Aremion und Wümpftlbrümpftl kommen mit ihren Ergebnissen nicht ganz an die anderen heran. Aremions Algorithmus bildet knapp das Schlusslicht, benötigt dafür aber auch nur durchschnittlich 26 Millisekunden, während der Rest fast immer die volle Zeit ausschöpft.
Interessant ist, dass Helmuts Teilpunktzahl für den Verlauf der Grenze (zählt zu 1/3) die niedrigste von allen ist. Dafür erzielt er aber die höchste Punktzahl bei der Teilpunktzahl für die Qualität der Aufteilung (zählt zu 2/3).
In der Statistik unten ist ein "optimaler" Algorithmus aufgeführt. Dieser funktioniert einfach so, dass er für jeden Planeten jeweils das beste Ergebnis aller Algorithmen liefert. Er ist rein fiktiv, zeigt aber, was theoretisch möglich gewesen wäre. Wie viel besser das absolute Maximum ist, bleibt ungewiss.

Ich danke allen für ihre Teilnahme! Insbesondere danke ich denjenigen, die trotz Unzufriedenheit mit ihrem Algorithmus etwas abgegeben haben! Dabeisein ist alles! Bis zum nächsten Mal!
Und natürlich mal wieder "Herzlichen Glückwunsch" an den alten Contest-Hasen Helmut! Du hast es echt drauf! :-)

Alle Lösungen sowie das Auswertungsprogramm können hier heruntergeladen werden.

Und nun viel Spaß mit den Ergebnissen! Ich habe mir mit der Auswertung viel Mühe gegeben. Alle Ergebnisse sämtlicher Planeten sind visualisiert. Einfach unten auf eine Planetennummer klicken, um die jeweiligen Lösungen anzuzeigen und sie zu vergleichen.

Übersicht

Name	Ø Punktzahl	Ø Grenzverlauf	Ø Aufteilung	Ø Zeit (ms)	Anzahl bester Lösungen
Aremion	0.736822	0.889842	0.660313	26	0
Darkrel	0.762987	0.854945	0.717008	997	0
David Scherfgen	0.789223	0.844469	0.7616	999	388
Helmut	0.789517	0.84183	0.763361	942	299
Wuempftlbruempftl	0.744864	0.883536	0.675528	995	0
"Optimaler" Algorithmus	0.789606	0.842006	0.763406	?	500

Punktzahlen bei den einzelnen Planeten

Klicke auf eine Planetennummer, um die Lösungen anzuzeigen.

Planet	Aremion	Darkrel	David Scherfgen	Helmut	Wuempftlbruempftl	"Optimaler" Algorithmus
000	0.756938	0.768756	0.783422	0.783422	0.733185	0.783422
001	0.7177	0.78259	0.79616	0.796163	0.78739	0.796163
002	0.737382	0.732849	0.772799	0.772664	0.713945	0.772799
003	0.701496	0.712635	0.727407	0.7274	0.71502	0.727407
004	0.750312	0.757912	0.763791	0.763791	0.752507	0.763791
005	0.621428	0.645413	0.667564	0.667514	0.58622	0.667564
006	0.832632	0.715448	0.859686	0.859686	0.77456	0.859686
007	0.665569	0.676788	0.70305	0.70305	0.646022	0.70305
008	0.729596	0.732865	0.773834	0.773836	0.755975	0.773836
009	0.805281	0.804664	0.838628	0.838628	0.749552	0.838628
010	0.663016	0.680928	0.730982	0.730986	0.702922	0.730986
011	0.628755	0.642611	0.662486	0.662486	0.625934	0.662486
012	0.757765	0.764185	0.776735	0.784497	0.747046	0.784497
013	0.590209	0.581058	0.64272	0.642726	0.571955	0.642726
014	0.784694	0.820543	0.837678	0.837678	0.725792	0.837678
015	0.778604	0.766861	0.811082	0.811068	0.782293	0.811082
016	0.580484	0.587852	0.617235	0.617235	0.551911	0.617235
017	0.639254	0.671896	0.682366	0.682366	0.618018	0.682366
018	0.565116	0.713562	0.73525	0.735239	0.732987	0.73525
019	0.60408	0.650174	0.680625	0.680612	0.599539	0.680625
020	0.727345	0.855587	0.866515	0.866515	0.678529	0.866515
021	0.743275	0.754728	0.766225	0.766222	0.65879	0.766225
022	0.577868	0.588383	0.643972	0.644122	0.595847	0.644122
023	0.881264	0.877554	0.892635	0.892635	0.874713	0.892635
024	0.839289	0.840486	0.881693	0.881611	0.854456	0.881693
025	0.90788	0.919942	0.924504	0.924587	0.717633	0.924587
026	0.734363	0.74243	0.767607	0.767829	0.668667	0.767829
027	0.661552	0.71781	0.749658	0.749658	0.675172	0.749658
028	0.534414	0.542898	0.55054	0.567542	0.528562	0.567542
029	0.766808	0.75775	0.779377	0.779355	0.738227	0.779377
030	0.640278	0.654188	0.671622	0.671411	0.649629	0.671622
031	0.926744	0.936477	0.942699	0.942699	0.934914	0.942699
032	0.727114	0.732577	0.74685	0.74685	0.730629	0.74685
033	0.909293	0.909128	0.920047	0.920087	0.912075	0.920087
034	0.653909	0.665213	0.67983	0.679814	0.667682	0.67983
035	0.768577	0.773692	0.803954	0.803954	0.795922	0.803954
036	0.885584	0.893212	0.904413	0.904413	0.888609	0.904413
037	0.664269	0.702993	0.756389	0.756389	0.688161	0.756389
038	0.562574	0.635853	0.652966	0.652966	0.636461	0.652966
039	0.86854	0.861092	0.88702	0.88702	0.876069	0.88702
040	0.624344	0.671624	0.699645	0.699639	0.623519	0.699645
041	0.865581	0.865844	0.883557	0.883557	0.879415	0.883557
042	0.666879	0.659279	0.6771	0.681243	0.668373	0.681243
043	0.626546	0.762867	0.801716	0.801716	0.756466	0.801716
044	0.601695	0.630667	0.66293	0.662924	0.586825	0.66293
045	0.546196	0.639159	0.673821	0.673804	0.579975	0.673821
046	0.641397	0.689659	0.707442	0.707333	0.699755	0.707442
047	0.55688	0.565712	0.573254	0.573254	0.556732	0.573254
048	0.831672	0.83309	0.852976	0.852976	0.835473	0.852976
049	0.578527	0.623713	0.640197	0.640197	0.580476	0.640197
050	0.625092	0.686709	0.715847	0.714345	0.697658	0.715847
051	0.919658	0.924766	0.937032	0.936992	0.926344	0.937032
052	0.811602	0.827933	0.857051	0.857051	0.792799	0.857051
053	0.593555	0.624081	0.654385	0.646819	0.579107	0.654385
054	0.626931	0.64987	0.678723	0.678731	0.577627	0.678731
055	0.815521	0.801931	0.83153	0.83153	0.809598	0.83153
056	0.646883	0.683915	0.710443	0.710443	0.614452	0.710443
057	0.588162	0.730754	0.759243	0.759243	0.728746	0.759243
058	0.768667	0.777014	0.7971	0.797094	0.766163	0.7971
059	0.722159	0.728057	0.758954	0.758954	0.736709	0.758954
060	0.710968	0.738972	0.773905	0.773905	0.717571	0.773905
061	0.675303	0.688629	0.720539	0.720545	0.695848	0.720545
062	0.809561	0.819321	0.833092	0.833044	0.811796	0.833092
063	0.770275	0.780665	0.806445	0.806439	0.74345	0.806445
064	0.824783	0.786615	0.843413	0.843421	0.81859	0.843421
065	0.561919	0.602751	0.643732	0.643732	0.534922	0.643732
066	0.668435	0.651167	0.684356	0.684356	0.611073	0.684356
067	0.594417	0.608528	0.627923	0.627894	0.575634	0.627923
068	0.845088	0.841891	0.871364	0.871363	0.865573	0.871364
069	0.756368	0.753028	0.775732	0.775732	0.708874	0.775732
070	0.698676	0.727678	0.755665	0.755665	0.738437	0.755665
071	0.726364	0.797487	0.808512	0.808505	0.719657	0.808512
072	0.810954	0.796201	0.825719	0.825719	0.817398	0.825719
073	0.773221	0.834234	0.848171	0.848764	0.825578	0.848764
074	0.59584	0.674547	0.690168	0.690162	0.583414	0.690168
075	0.791184	0.769517	0.806139	0.806126	0.764736	0.806139
076	0.857262	0.862521	0.875755	0.875729	0.716833	0.875755
077	0.659016	0.760226	0.777131	0.777128	0.737979	0.777131
078	0.776854	0.800968	0.819243	0.819245	0.751093	0.819245
079	0.637474	0.777386	0.811394	0.811357	0.796326	0.811394
080	0.666239	0.676613	0.690124	0.690124	0.665285	0.690124
081	0.632057	0.6996	0.711761	0.711761	0.649911	0.711761
082	0.803059	0.806766	0.834239	0.834239	0.828156	0.834239
083	0.73502	0.782814	0.799715	0.799715	0.680099	0.799715
084	0.7548	0.787164	0.810042	0.810058	0.755259	0.810058
085	0.71027	0.716965	0.728531	0.728531	0.651053	0.728531
086	0.585045	0.589336	0.600153	0.600153	0.588561	0.600153
087	0.77351	0.776463	0.801612	0.805639	0.761324	0.805639
088	0.824145	0.803936	0.838182	0.838263	0.82828	0.838263
089	0.701957	0.720055	0.760547	0.760559	0.746802	0.760559
090	0.738284	0.769458	0.788458	0.788453	0.766917	0.788458
091	0.636141	0.66075	0.695152	0.695141	0.658853	0.695152
092	0.706469	0.722114	0.745562	0.745562	0.635008	0.745562
093	0.648984	0.67336	0.702315	0.702306	0.676845	0.702315
094	0.769714	0.76664	0.804867	0.804867	0.707581	0.804867
095	0.807621	0.794091	0.823613	0.82326	0.788122	0.823613
096	0.565959	0.659582	0.683283	0.682595	0.647654	0.684145
097	0.754705	0.829832	0.842211	0.842204	0.692445	0.842211
098	0.729929	0.762009	0.836222	0.836222	0.813433	0.836222
099	0.818442	0.827593	0.842812	0.842553	0.827352	0.842812
100	0.653935	0.710804	0.724807	0.724807	0.639145	0.724807
101	0.911582	0.910084	0.928788	0.928766	0.920482	0.928788
102	0.723279	0.755807	0.785405	0.78538	0.734543	0.785405
103	0.52585	0.577153	0.606872	0.606872	0.540763	0.606872
104	0.650741	0.643268	0.678016	0.678016	0.590663	0.678016
105	0.627193	0.705351	0.725213	0.725279	0.636888	0.725279
106	0.686109	0.745639	0.78513	0.78512	0.690921	0.78513
107	0.80715	0.781474	0.824757	0.82446	0.81899	0.824757
108	0.777636	0.767917	0.793286	0.793286	0.785078	0.793286
109	0.600879	0.626978	0.73054	0.712094	0.710971	0.73054
110	0.687716	0.686087	0.707525	0.707525	0.635505	0.707525
111	0.638444	0.677184	0.699882	0.699873	0.649168	0.699882
112	0.667197	0.797265	0.806176	0.806166	0.687405	0.806176
113	0.842389	0.882059	0.895077	0.895068	0.807514	0.895077
114	0.86936	0.856357	0.879225	0.879225	0.87561	0.879225
115	0.852493	0.861624	0.880266	0.88026	0.865249	0.880266
116	0.775529	0.829319	0.843265	0.843265	0.809603	0.843265
117	0.557931	0.71885	0.753134	0.753125	0.688606	0.753134
118	0.728288	0.730622	0.763617	0.763624	0.722881	0.763624
119	0.877152	0.838912	0.889964	0.889964	0.878483	0.889964
120	0.823043	0.840628	0.857717	0.857717	0.855356	0.857717
121	0.792605	0.819407	0.834024	0.834028	0.811032	0.834028
122	0.622799	0.790619	0.80773	0.807733	0.765214	0.807733
123	0.567749	0.668055	0.715401	0.715401	0.682011	0.715401
124	0.792364	0.767771	0.815948	0.815939	0.78334	0.815948
125	0.742417	0.741188	0.777913	0.777932	0.762026	0.777932
126	0.605234	0.703449	0.716236	0.716251	0.671244	0.716251
127	0.838014	0.824031	0.855257	0.855257	0.810436	0.855257
128	0.809871	0.798911	0.827865	0.827829	0.81899	0.827865
129	0.62564	0.708824	0.737107	0.737107	0.642004	0.737107
130	0.67889	0.672156	0.712966	0.712959	0.575315	0.712966
131	0.682556	0.71767	0.731103	0.731077	0.670817	0.731103
132	0.712394	0.709286	0.736346	0.736319	0.648627	0.736346
133	0.863388	0.872883	0.886886	0.8869	0.883418	0.8869
134	0.691933	0.796647	0.813614	0.813614	0.810453	0.813614
135	0.930586	0.921913	0.941476	0.941463	0.937414	0.941476
136	0.673118	0.684463	0.725016	0.749824	0.711533	0.749824
137	0.912872	0.903477	0.920929	0.920375	0.919263	0.920929
138	0.708773	0.718386	0.732549	0.732512	0.711629	0.732549
139	0.760101	0.77081	0.805374	0.805374	0.761512	0.805374
140	0.755151	0.754499	0.790478	0.790478	0.760339	0.790478
141	0.837155	0.834538	0.857721	0.857634	0.835165	0.857721
142	0.729664	0.774737	0.793923	0.793923	0.788916	0.793923
143	0.85737	0.851486	0.870898	0.870877	0.865601	0.870898
144	0.72192	0.793133	0.80739	0.807348	0.710066	0.80739
145	0.843277	0.840985	0.860529	0.860529	0.765055	0.860529
146	0.57848	0.578466	0.597382	0.597382	0.542431	0.597382
147	0.64572	0.683554	0.698497	0.698491	0.64158	0.698497
148	0.539717	0.63159	0.652479	0.652489	0.515781	0.652489
149	0.759992	0.74873	0.785048	0.787589	0.765117	0.787589
150	0.678816	0.783286	0.814352	0.814352	0.806153	0.814352
151	0.666822	0.695324	0.697752	0.728879	0.709543	0.728879
152	0.830718	0.856585	0.873303	0.873024	0.790974	0.873303
153	0.614512	0.728441	0.75574	0.75574	0.720894	0.75574
154	0.607916	0.6705	0.686028	0.686028	0.635464	0.686028
155	0.721764	0.762178	0.784887	0.784887	0.710945	0.784887
156	0.753188	0.776835	0.811241	0.811241	0.798102	0.811241
157	0.643066	0.709293	0.731185	0.731189	0.681816	0.731189
158	0.797008	0.806743	0.824122	0.824479	0.814782	0.824479
159	0.829859	0.807683	0.859547	0.859547	0.830627	0.859547
160	0.798969	0.805406	0.867202	0.867258	0.8411	0.867258
161	0.892114	0.892361	0.910326	0.910326	0.902204	0.910326
162	0.86256	0.827627	0.877494	0.877494	0.875229	0.877494
163	0.547586	0.711359	0.73513	0.735248	0.580912	0.735248
164	0.815337	0.833916	0.852842	0.852838	0.716364	0.852842
165	0.793097	0.80244	0.828689	0.828689	0.812883	0.828689
166	0.798506	0.797695	0.822786	0.822786	0.815008	0.822786
167	0.568221	0.577531	0.588276	0.588287	0.538045	0.588287
168	0.841267	0.850293	0.867556	0.867556	0.696232	0.867556
169	0.817144	0.818205	0.84874	0.84874	0.819563	0.84874
170	0.948004	0.940482	0.956714	0.95671	0.946396	0.956714
171	0.670303	0.719902	0.771902	0.771826	0.731621	0.771902
172	0.809135	0.830455	0.846519	0.846519	0.724353	0.846519
173	0.6736	0.796606	0.816466	0.816443	0.729475	0.816466
174	0.638874	0.697944	0.707808	0.707808	0.674492	0.707808
175	0.715363	0.743753	0.764562	0.764641	0.731816	0.764641
176	0.880772	0.871305	0.899971	0.899971	0.896497	0.899971
177	0.620475	0.697662	0.762476	0.762476	0.695816	0.762476
178	0.799384	0.780339	0.818703	0.818703	0.741811	0.818703
179	0.65045	0.759214	0.777784	0.777777	0.760446	0.777784
180	0.597983	0.704244	0.74118	0.741168	0.66175	0.74118
181	0.635583	0.637489	0.645366	0.645364	0.599657	0.645366
182	0.813068	0.817621	0.843388	0.843245	0.821664	0.843388
183	0.863478	0.856044	0.880736	0.880718	0.870559	0.880736
184	0.699168	0.74253	0.758277	0.758272	0.668641	0.758277
185	0.818027	0.82299	0.864987	0.864992	0.832666	0.864992
186	0.550687	0.683303	0.717744	0.718262	0.707941	0.718262
187	0.887101	0.88916	0.91806	0.918063	0.879315	0.918063
188	0.832636	0.817802	0.852276	0.85212	0.797218	0.852276
189	0.617567	0.633814	0.660456	0.660473	0.617781	0.660473
190	0.734575	0.734821	0.763727	0.763564	0.739029	0.763727
191	0.954906	0.957597	0.961769	0.961765	0.958516	0.961769
192	0.674451	0.758403	0.790582	0.79058	0.743967	0.790582
193	0.827124	0.831044	0.861977	0.86195	0.840632	0.861977
194	0.655892	0.7117	0.739165	0.739165	0.663034	0.739165
195	0.76025	0.760964	0.796296	0.796235	0.775186	0.796296
196	0.784501	0.753896	0.805653	0.805656	0.784491	0.805656
197	0.640994	0.710582	0.745945	0.745942	0.715003	0.745945
198	0.93224	0.924628	0.941314	0.941314	0.940096	0.941314
199	0.578393	0.592401	0.628553	0.628553	0.5379	0.628553
200	0.830045	0.826271	0.849923	0.849923	0.84458	0.849923
201	0.828702	0.824656	0.84815	0.84815	0.79982	0.84815
202	0.906783	0.897014	0.920704	0.920684	0.913445	0.920704
203	0.729626	0.718742	0.748452	0.748452	0.625588	0.748452
204	0.566026	0.618512	0.690581	0.690577	0.640724	0.690581
205	0.568305	0.681672	0.707257	0.707229	0.702518	0.707257
206	0.683632	0.701384	0.728581	0.728581	0.646925	0.728581
207	0.840585	0.85402	0.86302	0.863006	0.800418	0.86302
208	0.843164	0.836738	0.857709	0.857706	0.842023	0.857709
209	0.584082	0.716969	0.753236	0.753236	0.679794	0.753236
210	0.711877	0.723405	0.736877	0.736887	0.700083	0.736887
211	0.87655	0.872554	0.897605	0.897605	0.883916	0.897605
212	0.729381	0.750771	0.797381	0.79738	0.749751	0.797381
213	0.647115	0.694589	0.706709	0.711802	0.640142	0.711802
214	0.816787	0.824306	0.84133	0.840492	0.834869	0.84133
215	0.748653	0.764109	0.807143	0.807127	0.776684	0.807143
216	0.657325	0.687035	0.746333	0.746333	0.701635	0.746333
217	0.625522	0.641925	0.665864	0.66585	0.64714	0.665864
218	0.699676	0.732011	0.759103	0.759094	0.718894	0.759103
219	0.873852	0.880048	0.894319	0.89424	0.886961	0.894319
220	0.819601	0.852853	0.89428	0.894209	0.854674	0.89428
221	0.738494	0.735404	0.751398	0.751398	0.731359	0.751398
222	0.589012	0.779221	0.818416	0.818416	0.784264	0.818416
223	0.811058	0.773235	0.835064	0.834941	0.817214	0.835064
224	0.815465	0.807141	0.83907	0.83907	0.792447	0.83907
225	0.812531	0.816187	0.830049	0.830049	0.813969	0.830049
226	0.763288	0.804329	0.824601	0.824605	0.709289	0.824605
227	0.761048	0.710208	0.777518	0.777518	0.730845	0.777518
228	0.838636	0.808051	0.855451	0.855451	0.847013	0.855451
229	0.904639	0.907742	0.920064	0.920109	0.917019	0.920109
230	0.724405	0.69893	0.72708	0.739135	0.631385	0.739135
231	0.774676	0.781781	0.803119	0.8029	0.782212	0.803119
232	0.713545	0.733269	0.755124	0.754943	0.753381	0.755124
233	0.60219	0.654395	0.672906	0.672903	0.609844	0.672906
234	0.686111	0.784734	0.801945	0.799419	0.708509	0.801945
235	0.757515	0.734484	0.774487	0.774487	0.628913	0.774487
236	0.651542	0.680005	0.699963	0.699959	0.679666	0.699963
237	0.88362	0.890524	0.904266	0.904266	0.89527	0.904266
238	0.65319	0.817527	0.83488	0.834876	0.690452	0.83488
239	0.685588	0.712182	0.726548	0.725648	0.69497	0.726548
240	0.862099	0.863467	0.88218	0.882153	0.869894	0.88218
241	0.854969	0.839722	0.874307	0.874296	0.853425	0.874307
242	0.824263	0.818035	0.844441	0.844441	0.822485	0.844441
243	0.610155	0.624574	0.658126	0.658112	0.623462	0.658126
244	0.75029	0.758803	0.772348	0.772393	0.712447	0.772393
245	0.845752	0.843189	0.880488	0.880488	0.681149	0.880488
246	0.707744	0.765366	0.784422	0.786209	0.684837	0.786209
247	0.71186	0.755203	0.786001	0.785974	0.626407	0.786001
248	0.646826	0.636154	0.669096	0.669096	0.586683	0.669096
249	0.643204	0.650167	0.69406	0.694046	0.643956	0.69406
250	0.526814	0.590812	0.629337	0.629337	0.525601	0.629337
251	0.756646	0.757941	0.781898	0.781896	0.760903	0.781898
252	0.671866	0.689899	0.722256	0.722259	0.68586	0.722259
253	0.756755	0.749995	0.820511	0.820501	0.771798	0.820511
254	0.75378	0.785034	0.811943	0.811952	0.724234	0.811952
255	0.532198	0.6333	0.662901	0.662901	0.606351	0.662901
256	0.672346	0.710974	0.753639	0.753633	0.657896	0.753639
257	0.770016	0.78167	0.800131	0.800131	0.791072	0.800131
258	0.663579	0.737392	0.752732	0.752734	0.640823	0.752734
259	0.950685	0.943918	0.960355	0.960355	0.95881	0.960355
260	0.726122	0.728937	0.749742	0.74972	0.714594	0.749742
261	0.794316	0.79836	0.828784	0.829311	0.802434	0.829311
262	0.754054	0.763312	0.791247	0.791614	0.771926	0.791614
263	0.883262	0.877834	0.897434	0.897403	0.89546	0.897434
264	0.898042	0.883659	0.908153	0.908153	0.902837	0.908153
265	0.902095	0.88659	0.91335	0.91335	0.904615	0.91335
266	0.714841	0.721609	0.73306	0.733065	0.636938	0.733065
267	0.846273	0.848456	0.871295	0.871303	0.8224	0.871303
268	0.761201	0.783898	0.791335	0.791303	0.732405	0.791335
269	0.616896	0.808796	0.820997	0.820997	0.711879	0.820997
270	0.867722	0.896315	0.911504	0.911723	0.674508	0.911723
271	0.708042	0.727513	0.754057	0.75405	0.65824	0.754057
272	0.64988	0.723083	0.811037	0.811037	0.772355	0.811037
273	0.550414	0.755369	0.768339	0.768338	0.674433	0.768339
274	0.740426	0.731853	0.753279	0.753263	0.741507	0.753279
275	0.769544	0.779545	0.800455	0.800447	0.733006	0.800455
276	0.603846	0.625968	0.658007	0.657822	0.58387	0.658007
277	0.629302	0.648304	0.660478	0.660681	0.644985	0.660681
278	0.658724	0.680961	0.709751	0.709748	0.684286	0.709751
279	0.649038	0.646792	0.685513	0.685543	0.609689	0.685543
280	0.837283	0.830576	0.853953	0.853946	0.825122	0.853953
281	0.811347	0.841784	0.853343	0.85333	0.852473	0.853343
282	0.773916	0.792049	0.813489	0.813429	0.807928	0.813489
283	0.514479	0.70708	0.730369	0.730366	0.68122	0.730369
284	0.681234	0.734491	0.777992	0.777986	0.719469	0.777992
285	0.575641	0.697794	0.746845	0.746845	0.703235	0.746845
286	0.770896	0.776223	0.798279	0.798279	0.764751	0.798279
287	0.844695	0.835225	0.860611	0.860611	0.847023	0.860611
288	0.726031	0.732798	0.748826	0.748831	0.732286	0.748831
289	0.91397	0.896034	0.926591	0.926591	0.919588	0.926591
290	0.849171	0.835522	0.882236	0.882236	0.869377	0.882236
291	0.742579	0.709084	0.76587	0.7658	0.688015	0.76587
292	0.695404	0.716617	0.747457	0.747457	0.711077	0.747457
293	0.940042	0.938616	0.949431	0.949431	0.947194	0.949431
294	0.758846	0.769659	0.787953	0.78795	0.775141	0.787953
295	0.849779	0.862333	0.874604	0.874302	0.86952	0.874604
296	0.887584	0.899466	0.911701	0.911678	0.895936	0.911701
297	0.707722	0.769265	0.78558	0.785552	0.709952	0.78558
298	0.856628	0.889609	0.915022	0.914462	0.69366	0.915022
299	0.818739	0.833257	0.839894	0.839894	0.834984	0.839894
300	0.759413	0.736391	0.826787	0.826784	0.79572	0.826787
301	0.78963	0.773955	0.802557	0.802557	0.778762	0.802557
302	0.80423	0.805312	0.822256	0.821768	0.765627	0.822256
303	0.724121	0.775931	0.811766	0.811766	0.769644	0.811766
304	0.909347	0.906201	0.930039	0.930039	0.885713	0.930039
305	0.826054	0.832905	0.851221	0.85122	0.840468	0.851221
306	0.769585	0.72735	0.799718	0.799718	0.779705	0.799718
307	0.711633	0.768348	0.795026	0.795026	0.74289	0.795026
308	0.729432	0.72452	0.754822	0.754822	0.685059	0.754822
309	0.705141	0.808243	0.821707	0.821954	0.669691	0.821954
310	0.511336	0.613035	0.638131	0.638131	0.53929	0.638131
311	0.839459	0.827977	0.864471	0.864467	0.847321	0.864471
312	0.69232	0.718942	0.760397	0.760206	0.725121	0.760397
313	0.905171	0.906033	0.922119	0.922278	0.919356	0.922278
314	0.715763	0.721383	0.772591	0.772739	0.653285	0.77274
315	0.741103	0.739923	0.762476	0.762961	0.738276	0.762961
316	0.840712	0.816663	0.860668	0.860668	0.825029	0.860668
317	0.724504	0.757645	0.773594	0.773594	0.711907	0.773594
318	0.883338	0.871861	0.899009	0.899002	0.896318	0.899009
319	0.751115	0.768138	0.779837	0.779837	0.772435	0.779837
320	0.663017	0.760099	0.781293	0.781404	0.764024	0.781404
321	0.620115	0.631066	0.640268	0.643816	0.615021	0.643816
322	0.67481	0.669471	0.725163	0.725163	0.660405	0.725163
323	0.781944	0.753222	0.801499	0.801432	0.720445	0.801499
324	0.905263	0.906546	0.919309	0.919356	0.912841	0.919356
325	0.751687	0.755508	0.797727	0.797638	0.78624	0.797727
326	0.632297	0.791828	0.815461	0.815461	0.798249	0.815461
327	0.704569	0.695152	0.742387	0.742258	0.727994	0.742387
328	0.79842	0.787676	0.816441	0.816435	0.731659	0.816441
329	0.687804	0.801631	0.813433	0.813433	0.667594	0.813433
330	0.879757	0.862914	0.890927	0.89087	0.881148	0.890927
331	0.75113	0.81285	0.847316	0.847316	0.806412	0.847316
332	0.875106	0.878209	0.885177	0.885113	0.872292	0.885177
333	0.700027	0.77377	0.813561	0.813566	0.792098	0.813566
334	0.921034	0.90914	0.9324	0.9324	0.92815	0.9324
335	0.760404	0.787614	0.801678	0.801678	0.779526	0.801678
336	0.84784	0.829245	0.865236	0.865233	0.84881	0.865236
337	0.881604	0.883095	0.891212	0.891191	0.879972	0.891212
338	0.872522	0.87705	0.881904	0.881908	0.867636	0.881908
339	0.836702	0.834755	0.84942	0.851102	0.849893	0.851102
340	0.764123	0.784203	0.799461	0.799461	0.724859	0.799461
341	0.623336	0.73485	0.784641	0.784641	0.758741	0.784641
342	0.763409	0.795914	0.812607	0.812607	0.80671	0.812607
343	0.812446	0.80889	0.833289	0.833289	0.807169	0.833289
344	0.754655	0.764526	0.782834	0.782834	0.77395	0.782834
345	0.651948	0.713752	0.72783	0.727825	0.65268	0.72783
346	0.766496	0.767328	0.791697	0.791698	0.732991	0.791698
347	0.544781	0.707061	0.765636	0.765626	0.697242	0.765636
348	0.89656	0.881402	0.912295	0.912017	0.911164	0.912295
349	0.639872	0.710271	0.735429	0.735429	0.681918	0.735429
350	0.831197	0.827568	0.856563	0.856473	0.810238	0.856563
351	0.862229	0.864042	0.874524	0.874498	0.868656	0.874524
352	0.62172	0.635316	0.679772	0.679774	0.629817	0.679774
353	0.662681	0.67073	0.679562	0.683741	0.62245	0.683741
354	0.721659	0.747294	0.772835	0.77277	0.751812	0.772835
355	0.723436	0.751037	0.76175	0.766856	0.743763	0.766856
356	0.634493	0.748403	0.784521	0.784521	0.729487	0.784521
357	0.619797	0.648101	0.670969	0.670969	0.628059	0.670969
358	0.662746	0.666111	0.714869	0.715022	0.705431	0.715022
359	0.651752	0.638994	0.680424	0.6799	0.509386	0.680424
360	0.657194	0.721012	0.73597	0.73598	0.698511	0.73598
361	0.832878	0.808359	0.857871	0.858998	0.840518	0.858998
362	0.563194	0.623234	0.651502	0.651501	0.544701	0.651502
363	0.77132	0.815128	0.854122	0.854122	0.837575	0.854122
364	0.841994	0.838804	0.862584	0.862553	0.853271	0.862584
365	0.678572	0.675858	0.720157	0.720139	0.687315	0.720157
366	0.69073	0.748898	0.767268	0.767534	0.617994	0.767534
367	0.807283	0.799536	0.816218	0.816184	0.814366	0.816218
368	0.744637	0.747037	0.778724	0.778817	0.745529	0.778817
369	0.59945	0.600887	0.614774	0.614773	0.585642	0.614774
370	0.671695	0.702417	0.737251	0.737251	0.658489	0.737251
371	0.758221	0.782472	0.821582	0.821581	0.756207	0.821582
372	0.757325	0.742094	0.777097	0.777063	0.769775	0.777097
373	0.75818	0.75924	0.78609	0.786052	0.711783	0.78609
374	0.638183	0.706008	0.728177	0.728177	0.685922	0.728177
375	0.874979	0.850974	0.890634	0.890723	0.877008	0.890723
376	0.749006	0.729695	0.78464	0.784072	0.755539	0.78464
377	0.670914	0.775335	0.785299	0.785291	0.759501	0.785299
378	0.717008	0.724515	0.765498	0.765492	0.741777	0.765498
379	0.809591	0.819153	0.84446	0.844064	0.722752	0.84446
380	0.895706	0.910076	0.923214	0.923113	0.914789	0.923214
381	0.80091	0.827517	0.837701	0.837719	0.825105	0.837719
382	0.736922	0.750513	0.755739	0.755739	0.732482	0.755739
383	0.837563	0.827611	0.857916	0.857921	0.825465	0.857921
384	0.727453	0.764353	0.786288	0.78633	0.779684	0.78633
385	0.852028	0.861246	0.877897	0.877878	0.857986	0.877897
386	0.613827	0.790706	0.805173	0.805173	0.775934	0.805173
387	0.786685	0.763599	0.812483	0.812483	0.787524	0.812483
388	0.700114	0.707678	0.733854	0.733842	0.708506	0.733854
389	0.785022	0.820104	0.840965	0.840964	0.778285	0.840965
390	0.589017	0.678739	0.69694	0.696763	0.637391	0.69694
391	0.886077	0.896079	0.906862	0.906853	0.904185	0.906862
392	0.537627	0.659277	0.696136	0.696136	0.630957	0.696136
393	0.855697	0.85882	0.881711	0.88149	0.854439	0.881711
394	0.800645	0.7961	0.829474	0.829474	0.788986	0.829474
395	0.647031	0.735863	0.806867	0.806866	0.773365	0.806867
396	0.765551	0.808183	0.823149	0.823128	0.705919	0.823149
397	0.549083	0.627062	0.641817	0.641817	0.606036	0.641817
398	0.823688	0.800016	0.840448	0.840448	0.820776	0.840448
399	0.83303	0.798742	0.853054	0.853014	0.847356	0.853054
400	0.566947	0.749874	0.778995	0.779041	0.75827	0.779041
401	0.724827	0.763435	0.775955	0.775955	0.74252	0.775955
402	0.801961	0.80338	0.817505	0.817505	0.799008	0.817505
403	0.821206	0.811484	0.846254	0.846254	0.830299	0.846254
404	0.602939	0.623799	0.646569	0.646569	0.61491	0.646569
405	0.746144	0.755323	0.777799	0.777675	0.683819	0.777799
406	0.746423	0.765211	0.775349	0.775159	0.753879	0.775349
407	0.567391	0.606884	0.628544	0.628544	0.600975	0.628544
408	0.630489	0.671986	0.694045	0.694044	0.660285	0.694045
409	0.659529	0.681074	0.702669	0.702664	0.662126	0.702669
410	0.777321	0.795258	0.813721	0.813721	0.793636	0.813721
411	0.727578	0.777869	0.812655	0.812649	0.80263	0.812655
412	0.718912	0.746697	0.773418	0.77347	0.729231	0.77347
413	0.840929	0.839883	0.859098	0.859091	0.74693	0.859098
414	0.833105	0.84241	0.850086	0.850086	0.844856	0.850086
415	0.587838	0.620276	0.631278	0.631278	0.56295	0.631278
416	0.757624	0.736041	0.806737	0.806712	0.792473	0.806737
417	0.68944	0.719605	0.738802	0.741589	0.653466	0.741589
418	0.646208	0.755302	0.776291	0.7763	0.771082	0.7763
419	0.609376	0.625313	0.643282	0.643282	0.598962	0.643282
420	0.890344	0.892368	0.901103	0.901982	0.895493	0.901982
421	0.661457	0.679604	0.707746	0.707746	0.701525	0.707746
422	0.930925	0.933284	0.939402	0.939405	0.930289	0.939405
423	0.654086	0.721087	0.734378	0.734378	0.642064	0.734378
424	0.738816	0.767164	0.797188	0.797415	0.75247	0.797415
425	0.706099	0.772013	0.778117	0.778105	0.686561	0.778117
426	0.805887	0.814356	0.844215	0.844215	0.837368	0.844215
427	0.886646	0.884103	0.893024	0.893024	0.882689	0.893024
428	0.689653	0.694555	0.71056	0.710562	0.702487	0.710562
429	0.819635	0.827912	0.852901	0.852894	0.754305	0.852901
430	0.719978	0.771996	0.793439	0.793477	0.654224	0.793477
431	0.79957	0.814764	0.834497	0.834807	0.78731	0.834807
432	0.787474	0.774109	0.811581	0.811581	0.771181	0.811581
433	0.812808	0.816059	0.835991	0.835991	0.816378	0.835991
434	0.688478	0.731072	0.770968	0.770968	0.745499	0.770968
435	0.848513	0.834384	0.871011	0.871018	0.862464	0.871018
436	0.819495	0.828252	0.859009	0.859007	0.831866	0.859009
437	0.680627	0.709153	0.734326	0.734318	0.572641	0.734326
438	0.844138	0.82777	0.855502	0.855468	0.844934	0.855502
439	0.708541	0.709206	0.72973	0.729727	0.70803	0.72973
440	0.682767	0.701116	0.711674	0.711661	0.685738	0.711674
441	0.876236	0.886012	0.900866	0.90086	0.8595	0.900866
442	0.717231	0.72461	0.763465	0.763465	0.719595	0.763465
443	0.819424	0.829928	0.847081	0.847081	0.840462	0.847081
444	0.905614	0.887237	0.918565	0.918555	0.911097	0.918565
445	0.854196	0.85772	0.867403	0.867555	0.857751	0.867555
446	0.762365	0.781051	0.797878	0.797875	0.737677	0.797878
447	0.698719	0.693524	0.723192	0.72339	0.665868	0.72339
448	0.925001	0.933151	0.945189	0.94523	0.926815	0.94523
449	0.888932	0.866679	0.909092	0.909085	0.906348	0.909092
450	0.787225	0.790293	0.807922	0.807922	0.772901	0.807922
451	0.853029	0.857793	0.869182	0.869182	0.862962	0.869182
452	0.787672	0.800507	0.820198	0.820198	0.811341	0.820198
453	0.646252	0.642331	0.681689	0.68365	0.658972	0.68365
454	0.56758	0.635966	0.688861	0.688861	0.634621	0.688861
455	0.663047	0.822412	0.837249	0.837249	0.819824	0.837249
456	0.819277	0.829779	0.844819	0.844815	0.836548	0.844819
457	0.85932	0.846356	0.876158	0.876125	0.870506	0.876158
458	0.738519	0.727918	0.759238	0.759226	0.61224	0.759238
459	0.884375	0.898104	0.909468	0.909397	0.889802	0.909468
460	0.650119	0.750164	0.760132	0.760132	0.752679	0.760132
461	0.62907	0.683039	0.704648	0.704604	0.61361	0.704648
462	0.731493	0.735823	0.755049	0.755679	0.67891	0.755679
463	0.743362	0.749119	0.779952	0.779967	0.73697	0.779967
464	0.620408	0.772114	0.801854	0.801903	0.793863	0.801903
465	0.5829	0.649469	0.67001	0.670567	0.595983	0.670567
466	0.640426	0.801774	0.812834	0.812834	0.654792	0.812834
467	0.693887	0.716381	0.763586	0.763586	0.621084	0.763586
468	0.592311	0.662947	0.669886	0.677868	0.664522	0.677868
469	0.885642	0.868985	0.898193	0.898176	0.89412	0.898193
470	0.798513	0.805525	0.820252	0.820252	0.813281	0.820252
471	0.597794	0.597857	0.602448	0.602209	0.589913	0.602448
472	0.924554	0.920944	0.939764	0.939809	0.937498	0.939809
473	0.640013	0.693141	0.70087	0.710991	0.664799	0.710991
474	0.567636	0.58118	0.588245	0.617967	0.580633	0.617967
475	0.699577	0.727383	0.738406	0.738401	0.734212	0.738406
476	0.697562	0.735652	0.752136	0.752136	0.683083	0.752136
477	0.63757	0.739418	0.756358	0.756298	0.660249	0.756358
478	0.568065	0.57707	0.587293	0.589147	0.51333	0.589147
479	0.813913	0.824762	0.834547	0.834536	0.823736	0.834547
480	0.861853	0.853622	0.878465	0.87846	0.876388	0.878465
481	0.801014	0.838931	0.868442	0.868427	0.852263	0.868442
482	0.605907	0.761732	0.782807	0.782807	0.63192	0.782807
483	0.865484	0.876499	0.891379	0.891379	0.877077	0.891379
484	0.586591	0.729537	0.754667	0.754667	0.707436	0.754667
485	0.713336	0.693065	0.740507	0.740507	0.707204	0.740507
486	0.638384	0.650668	0.655836	0.655836	0.637759	0.655836
487	0.831974	0.821125	0.844148	0.844149	0.833978	0.844149
488	0.75346	0.779948	0.791607	0.791607	0.776497	0.791607
489	0.923782	0.905912	0.934925	0.934925	0.934368	0.934925
490	0.823738	0.828187	0.839453	0.83945	0.831147	0.839453
491	0.534282	0.566993	0.602445	0.602469	0.562191	0.602469
492	0.705481	0.795463	0.814739	0.815694	0.713663	0.815694
493	0.579969	0.623631	0.671455	0.671455	0.664181	0.671455
494	0.730209	0.774526	0.802856	0.802856	0.641697	0.802856
495	0.881569	0.873617	0.897116	0.897124	0.875635	0.897124
496	0.902142	0.91118	0.916101	0.916095	0.911079	0.916101
497	0.616451	0.694479	0.725245	0.725245	0.677799	0.725245
498	0.841272	0.855224	0.867388	0.867383	0.835906	0.867388
499	0.800239	0.826968	0.839744	0.839744	0.820861	0.839744